• Latest
  • Trending
Beyond Hong Kong, Media Ignores Global Protests

Beyond Hong Kong, Media Ignores Global Protests

November 4, 2019
Albanian Opposition Supports Government Earthquake Relief Efforts

Albanian Opposition Supports Government Earthquake Relief Efforts

December 3, 2019
IDF sends aid mission to earthquake-stricken Albania

IDF sends aid mission to earthquake-stricken Albania

December 3, 2019
Albania: Future uncertain for thousands of earthquake homeless

Albania: Future uncertain for thousands of earthquake homeless

December 3, 2019
YMCA Kosovo support Albanian families after deadly earthquake

YMCA Kosovo support Albanian families after deadly earthquake

December 1, 2019
Number of human trafficking cases dramatically increase in Belgium

Number of human trafficking cases dramatically increase in Belgium

December 1, 2019
EU mobilises emergency support to Albania after deadly earthquake

EU mobilises emergency support to Albania after deadly earthquake

December 1, 2019
Albania earthquake: Rescue efforts wind down

Albania earthquake: Rescue efforts wind down

November 30, 2019
Mayor Veliaj Uses Earthquake as Propaganda Opportunity

Mayor Veliaj Uses Earthquake as Propaganda Opportunity

November 30, 2019
Four Thousand Albanians Made Homeless after Devastating Earthquake

Four Thousand Albanians Made Homeless after Devastating Earthquake

November 29, 2019
Rama Announces Dubious Anti-corruption Legislation

Rama Announces Dubious Anti-corruption Legislation

November 29, 2019
Reports of Aid Being Refused in Camps, Arrests For Misapropriation

Reports of Aid Being Refused in Camps, Arrests For Misapropriation

November 29, 2019
Fear, evacuations and introspection in Albania after deadly quake

Fear, evacuations and introspection in Albania after deadly quake

November 29, 2019
Sunday, January 17, 2021
Tirana Chronicle
No Result
View All Result
  • Albanian News
  • World News
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
      • Mexico
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • National Security
    • Military
    • Politics
    • Terrorism
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science
  • Sports
    • Soccer
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • History
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests
  • Albanian News
  • World News
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
      • Mexico
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • National Security
    • Military
    • Politics
    • Terrorism
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science
  • Sports
    • Soccer
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • History
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests
No Result
View All Result
Tirana Chronicle
No Result
View All Result

Beyond Hong Kong, Media Ignores Global Protests

Mainstream media has covered Hong Kong's protests extensively, but ignored Haiti, Ecuador, Chile and elsewhere

November 4, 2019
in Asia, China, Economy, Featured, Law, National Security, Politics, World News
0
Home World News Asia
Post Views: 9

 

It’s all kicking off everywhere in 2019. Haitians are revolting against a corrupt political system and their President Jovenel Moïse, who many see as a kleptocratic U.S. puppet. In Ecuador, huge public manifestations managed to force President Lenín Moreno to backtrack on his IMF-backed neoliberal package that would have sharply cut government spending and increased transport prices (FAIR.org, 10/23/19).

Meanwhile, popular Chilean frustration at the conservative Piñera administration boiled over into massive protests that were immediately met with force. “We are at war,” announced President Sebastián Piñera, echoing the infamous catchphrase of former fascist dictator Augusto Pinochet. Piñera claimed that those responsible for violently resisting him were “going to pay for their deeds” as he ordered tanks through Santiago. (See FAIR.org, 10/23/19.)

Huge, ongoing anti-government demonstrations are also engulfing Lebanon, Catalonia and the United Kingdom.

RelatedPosts

Hong Kong Police identifies Universities as a breeding ground for extremism

Hong Kong Protesters Upgrade Weapons and Strategy

In protest-hit HK, eating out is political

Foreigners who join Hong Kong protests say they’re not interfering, just ‘showing solidarity’

Singapore police investigate Hong Kong protest bar meeting

PBS NewsHour (10/5/19)

Yet the actions that have by far received the most attention in corporate media are those in Hong Kong, where demonstrations erupted in response to a proposed extradition agreement with the Chinese central government that opponents felt would undermine civil liberties and Hong Kong’s semi-autonomous status. A search for “Hong Kong protests” on Oct. 25 elicits 282 responses in the last month in the New York Times, for example, compared to 20 for “Chile protests,” 43 for Ecuador and 16 for Haiti. The unequal coverage is even more pronounced on Fox News, where there were 70 results for Hong Kong over the same period and four, two and three for Chile, Ecuador and Haiti, respectively.

This disparity cannot be explained due to the protests’ size or significance, the number of casualties or the response from the authorities. Eighteen people have died during the ongoing protests in Haiti, 19 (and rising) in Chile, while in Ecuador, protesters themselves captured over 50 soldiers who had been sent in as Moreno effectively declared martial law. In contrast, no one has been killed in Hong Kong, nor has the army been called in, with Beijing expressing full confidence in local authorities to handle proceedings. The Chilean government announced it had arrested over 5,400 people in only a week of protests, a figure more than double the number arrested in months of Hong Kong demonstrations (Bloomberg, 10/4/19). Furthermore, social media have been awash with images and videos of the suppression of the protests worldwide.

One way of understanding why the media is fixated on Hong Kong and less interested in the others is to look at who is protesting, and why.

Worthy and unworthy victims

New York Times (8/14/19)

Over 30 years ago, in their book “Manufacturing Consent,” Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky developed their theory of worthy vs. unworthy victims to explain why corporate media cover certain stories and why others are dropped. They compared the media coverage of a single murdered priest in an enemy state (Communist Poland) to that of over 100 religious martyrs, including some U.S. citizens, murdered in Central American client states over a period of two decades. They found that not only did the New York Times, Time, Newsweek and CBS News dedicate more coverage to the single priest’s assassination, the tone of coverage was markedly different: In covering the killing of Father Jerzy Popieluszko, media expressed indignation, demanding justice and condemning the barbarism of Communism. The killings of religious figures in Central America by pro-U.S. government groups, on the other hand, were reported in a matter-of-fact manner, with little rhetorical outrage.

In other words, when official enemies can be presented as evil and allies as sympathetic victims, corporate media will be very interested in a story. In contrast, they will show far less enthusiasm for a story when the “wrong” people are the villains or the victims.

On Hong Kong, the New York Times has published three editorials (6/10/19, 8/14/19, 10/1/19), each lauding the “democracy-minded people” fighting to limit “the repressive rule of the Chinese Communists,” condemning the Communist response as evidence of the backward, “brutal paternalism of that system,” in which China “equates greatness with power and dissent with treachery.” Hong Kong, on the other hand, thanks to the blessing of being a former British colony, had acquired “a Western political culture of democracy, human rights, free speech and independent thought.” (The Times has not elected to publish any editorials on the other protests.)

The Times also ridiculed the idea that “foreign forces” (i.e., the U.S. government) could be influencing the protests, calling it a “shopworn canard” used by the Communist government. Yet the U.S. National Endowment for Democracy (NED) has officially poured over $22 million into “identifying new avenues for democracy and political reform in Hong Kong” or China since 2014. The Times editorials did not mention this funding as possibly complicating their dismissal of foreign involvement in the Hong Kong protests as a “canard.”

Guardian (10/8/19)

However, media (e.g., Voice of America, 10/11/19; Miami Herald, 10/9/19; Reuters, 10/9/19) are taking seriously the accusation that the Ecuadorian protests are, in fact, masterminded abroad, by President Nicolás Maduro of Venezuela, with the Guardian (10/8/19) going so far as to describe the Ecuadorian protesters not as “democracy-minded people,” but “rioters” — a label not appearing in connection with Hong Kong, except as an accusation by Chinese officials (e.g., Time, 10/2/19; CNN, 10/22/19), who are almost universally condemned in coverage as part of a “repressive” (e.g., Vox, 8/29/19; Guardian, 10/19/19) “dictatorship” (New York Times, 8/29/19).

In the cases of the less-covered protests, the “wrong” people are protesting and the “wrong” governments are doing the repressing. As the Washington Post (10/14/19) noted on Haiti,

One factor keeping Moïse in power is support from the United States. US officials have been limited in their public comments about the protests.

On Ecuador, the State Department has been more forthcoming, issuing a full endorsement of Moreno’s neoliberal austerity package:

The United States supports President Moreno and the Government of Ecuador’s efforts to institutionalize democratic practices and implement needed economic reforms…. We will continue to work in partnership with President Moreno in support of democracy, prosperity, and security.

In other words, don’t expect any angry editorials denouncing U.S. client states like Haiti or Ecuador, or arguing that the Chilean government’s repression of its protest movement shows the moral bankruptcy of capitalism. Indeed, corporate media (e.g., Guardian, 10/8/19; CNN, 10/8/19; USA Today, 10/10/19) emphasized the violence of the Ecuadorian protesters while downplaying Hong Kong’s — the New York Times (6/30/19) even inventing the phrase “aggressive nonviolence” to describe the Hong Kong protesters’ actions, so eager was it to frame the demonstrations against China as unquestionably laudable.

Which protest movements interest corporate media has little to do with their righteousness or popularity, and much more to do with whom they are protesting against. If you’re fighting against corporate power or corruption in a U.S. client state, don’t expect many TV cameras to show up; that revolution is rarely televised.

Source: Salon
Tags: Chilean governmentglobal protestsHong Kong ProtestPresident Jovenel MoïsePresident MorenoPresident Sebastian Piñera
ShareTweetShare

Related Posts

Albanian Opposition Supports Government Earthquake Relief Efforts
Albanian News

Albanian Opposition Supports Government Earthquake Relief Efforts

December 3, 2019
IDF sends aid mission to earthquake-stricken Albania
Albanian News

IDF sends aid mission to earthquake-stricken Albania

December 3, 2019
Albania: Future uncertain for thousands of earthquake homeless
Albanian News

Albania: Future uncertain for thousands of earthquake homeless

December 3, 2019
YMCA Kosovo support Albanian families after deadly earthquake
Albanian News

YMCA Kosovo support Albanian families after deadly earthquake

December 1, 2019
Number of human trafficking cases dramatically increase in Belgium
Albanian News

Number of human trafficking cases dramatically increase in Belgium

December 1, 2019
Next Post
Main sectors of Albania’s economy continue to improve: minister

Main sectors of Albania's economy continue to improve: minister

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

five × two =

Translate

Popular Post

Albanian Opposition Supports Government Earthquake Relief Efforts
Albanian News

Albanian Opposition Supports Government Earthquake Relief Efforts

December 3, 2019
0

  Democratic Party leader Lulzim Basha stated the opposition supports the government in its efforts to help citizens affected by...

Read more
Albania government denies links to organised crime

Albania government denies links to organised crime

May 30, 2019
The Brief: Western Balkans – a test for the EU’s expansion appetite

The Brief: Western Balkans – a test for the EU’s expansion appetite

May 31, 2019
Armaldo Kllogjeri to hold recital at Tirana’s Amphitheatre

Armaldo Kllogjeri to hold recital at Tirana’s Amphitheatre

May 31, 2019
Abu Sayyaf’s Dutch hostage killed in firefight in Sulu

Abu Sayyaf’s Dutch hostage killed in firefight in Sulu

June 1, 2019
  • About Us
  • Creative Commons
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Contact Us

Topics

Follow Us

About Us

Tiranachronicle.com is part of Tirana Chronicle Media Group LLC, which delivers daily news around the globe.

© 2011 Tirana Chronicle

No Result
View All Result
  • Albanian News
  • World News
    • Africa
    • Asia
      • China
      • North Korea
    • Canada
    • Europe
    • Latin America
      • Mexico
    • Middle East
    • Russian Federation
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • National Security
    • Military
    • Politics
    • Terrorism
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science
  • Sports
    • Soccer
    • Tennis
    • Olympics
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Books & Literature
    • Education
    • Family
    • Food & Drink
    • Health
    • History
  • Environment
    • Agriculture
    • Climate Change
    • Forests

© 2011 Tirana Chronicle